Like us on Facebook!
Pick Your Pie
  • Home
  • Catering
  • Wholesale
  • Pie Flavors
  • Locations
  • About
  • Recipes
Newsletter Sign Up
Call Now
Email Now
Picture
Treat your family to one of a kind pie experience and have us deliver your pie! ($3.00 delivery fee & location permitting). 
Please allow at least 24 hours from placing order to pick up/delivery. Closed Sundays.
See below for flavors and pricing(pricing reflects :

Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $10.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: 11.00 (Seasonal)
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: $12.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Price: $11.00
Picture
Pick Your Pie
5815B Mayfield Rd.
Mayfield Heights, OH 44124
Phone:440-565-7050
Email:info@pickyourpie.com
copyright 2017 Pick Your Pie LLC

​ Right on Mayfield Road between Lander and Brainard.
On the north side across from the House of Lights and Dunkin' Donuts.