Dessert Catering in Mayfield Heights, OH

Party Planning?

Pick Your Pie is a one-of-a-kind dessert option that is sure to wow your guests! Use Pick Your Pie to simplify your party planning; our pie keeps in the fridge for up to 48 hours, so you can pick it up ahead of time!
  • Pie flights give every guest their own dessert. And they're easy to transport in stackable cupcake containers!
  • Or set up a pie bar and let your guests make their own unique dessert!

Need a corporate catering solution?

Let us simplify your corporate party planning! Is your staff tired of the same old cookie tray or sheet cake? Pick Your Pie is a fantastic dessert catering option we guarantee they've never seen before!
  • We offer FREE delivery for corporate catering in the Mayfield Heights and South Euclid. (Minimum $100 order). Delivery is available outside this area for a small fee.
  • Let your staff make their own dessert with our catered pie bar, or give each staff member their own dessert with our pie flights!​
Companies we've served:

We offer catering for weddings!

Need an affordable dessert option that will impress your guests? Serve Pick Your Pie for only $3 per person!
  • Dozens of delicious options - choose one that fits your theme. We can even personalize your pie flights with a logo or monogram!
  • Made from scratch with no transfats or high fructose corn syrup, so you know you're serving your guests the very best.
  • When catering for weddings we offer free delivery in the Mayfield Heights and South Euclid areas (minimum $100 order). Delivery is available outside this area for a small charge.
Enjoy a homemade slice or family size pie but in a CUP! We believe in pie that is portable, delicious and contains no trans fats or high fructose corn syrup. Even if you don't like traditional pie, you will love us!. Our pie is mostly filling, our crusts are cookie based, and you can even choose toppings!
Picture

It's Pie in a Cup!
Enjoy a one of a kind & made from scratch slice of pie in a cup. It is sure to put a smile on your face!
Get your Pick Your Pie parfaits at our store in Mayfield Heights or at:
Whole Foods Market (University Heights (OH), Rocky River (OH) & Orange Village, (OH))
Constantino's Markets (West 9th, Lakewood & University Circle)
​Chuppa's Market (Parma, OH)
Cleveland Clinic Hospital Cafeterias
Notre Dame College
​Kent State University

Flavors